WHRnet Perspective - Barbara Ehrenreich

The Unexpected Lesson from Abu Ghraib

Iraq: Torture Survivors Await US Redress, Accountability | Human ...

The disturbing imagery that emerged from Abu Ghraib prison shocked the world, revealing the participation of women soldiers in acts of torture. As a committed feminist, this was a jarring revelation to confront – that having a uterus does not inherently instill a moral conscience.

Breaking Feminist Illusions

The presence of female perpetrators among the soldiers charged with these heinous acts at Abu Ghraib posed a direct challenge to longstanding feminist belief systems. It tested the perception of inherent gender-based moral superiority and brought forth the brutal truth: women can also be agents of violence and cruelty.

Military Women In the Spotlight

Female soldiers once represented a beacon of progress and hope for change within the military’s ranks. The involvement of Spc. Megan Ambuhl, Pfc. Lynndie England, and Spc. Sabrina Harman in the atrocities of Abu Ghraib weakened this hope, reflecting instead a harsh compatibility with the most execrable aspects of a misogynistic culture they were thought to oppose.

Confronting Naive Assumptions

Maggie Nelson on the Conversations She Wants to Be Having | The ...

The feminist movement has long harbored an image of women infusing institutions with inherently virtuous qualities. Ehrenreich’s introspection reveals the shortcomings of this perspective, acknowledging that both women and men are susceptible to the corruption of moral values in dehumanizing environments.

The Role of Female Leadership

The assumption that female leadership within military ranks could prevent such atrocities has also been scrutinized. High-ranking officials like Gen. Janis Karpinski showed that gender does not insulate against the compromise of ethical standards.

Learning from Abu Ghraib

The lessons of Abu Ghraib are profound, resonating with the grim acknowledgment that gender alone does not dictate moral fortitude. This realization mandates a reevaluation of feminist strategy, separating the pursuit of gender equality from the broader, essential pursuit of justice and peace.

A Call for a New Feminism

Ehrenreich calls for a fortified feminism, one estranged from illusions of moral superiority and committed to active resistance against oppressive frameworks. This renewed feminism focuses not merely on equal representation but on transforming the very institutions traditionally dominated by men.

Aspiring to the Ideal World

True equality must aspire to more than achieving parity in a flawed system; it must aim to uplift and restructure society to reflect justice, compassion, and respect for all individuals, transcending the limitations of gender stereotypes and expectations.

Travel and Social Consciousness

In much the same way as the struggle for authentic feminism requires an evolving understanding, the sphere of travel and hospitality can also be a platform for expressing values and enacting change. Consciousness-raising experiences during travel can influence our choices, from the destinations we select to the lodgings that we support, encouraging environments that foster respect for human rights and dignity. Just as we reimagine our institutions to reflect our highest ideals, we can also envision and patronize a travel industry that upholds ethical standards and promotes the welfare of all people, making each journey both a personal enrichment and a testament to our collective values.